Kyle and I have been weighing the pros and cons about holding Nate back a year. We came up with more pros than cons, and have decided that we will have Nate repeat first grade. There were many factors in our decision. A couple of the biggies were the move that disrupted the school year for him, and the fact that he is SO TINY. When I first approached the schools about plans for next year, they hadn't thought about holding him back. But then when they started thinking about it, everyone who works with Nate thought it would really be beneficial to have him repeat first grade.
I have felt that only now Nate is really integrated into his new classroom. This is nobody's fault, just a consequence of events. I have been more than happy with the schools in Grand Rapids. However, this means he has not had an optimal environment for more than half of his first grade experience. By holding him back, he will have the advantage he had in St. Louis Park of everyone knowing him, knowing what to expect of him, and knowing when to push and when to let him be. I know that he will always have a more difficult time than his peers, and he has always been slower than others. But, he does eventually get it. I don't expect this move to mean he will always be doing the same work that his classmates are doing. However, I feel he will be close.
The schools were a bit surprised to have parents so willing to take this step. Especially with the social stigma of having to repeat a grade (but lets be honest, Nate is always going to be different in one way or another). I think that if he was in the cities still with the same group of kids he has gone to school with for more than two years, I would think twice about this decision. But, this is really about what is best for Nate....and we feel we have made the right decision!
A blog for sharing stories about our family and our many adventures both big and small.
Tuesday, May 13, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
You Say Goodbye and I Say Hello
After saying goodbye to Lucy we knew we wanted another friend, and we also knew that a cat was more suitable to our busy lifestyle than anot...
-
One of the many hats I wear at Deer River HealthCare Center is that of a therapist educating individuals who are going to have the lap-band ...
-
I recently wrote up the following for a former classmate who had a recent eye cancer scare with her young baby. She had asked if I would sha...
Tracey,
ReplyDeleteI'm sure this was a very difficult decision, but as always I'm sure you're going to do right by Nate. I'm happy for you all that the decision making is over and you can move forward with the plan.
Love to all,
Darcie